PlaceDossier / Questions

What is a home appraisal in BC, and what happens if it comes in low?

An appraisal is one appraiser's opinion of what the home is worth on a given day; a lender lends on that value, not the price, so a low one leaves a gap you must fill.

Opens the lot's report at this answer. If an address isn't found, try the PID, the 9-digit parcel number on the land title or assessment notice.

Share

TextEmail

Text and Email open your messages or email app with this message, ready to edit.

What the answer means

A home appraisal is a written opinion of market value by an appraiser, most often ordered for a lender before it funds a mortgage. It isn't BC Assessment's value, which is set each year for property tax, and it isn't the price you agreed: when it comes in under the price, the lender lends on the lower figure.

Appraisal or assessment
BC Assessment's value is the property's market value as of July 1 of the year before the tax year, taken as if in the condition and permitted use it had on October 31 (Assessment Act s. 18), and it is set for property tax. An appraisal is an appraiser's independent opinion of value for a client and a specific purpose, on the day the appraiser reports (the Appraisal Institute of Canada's page for property owners). Neither is the price a buyer has to pay, and the two needn't agree (our reading).
Who may appraise
Advising on the appropriate price for real estate is a trading service, which needs a licence when done for pay (Real Estate Services Act ss. 1, 2 (1)), but a person who only appraises or consults on the value of real estate, in the course of their business as an appraiser, is exempt from that licence (Real Estate Services Regulation s. 2.8 (a)). We found no BC statute that licenses appraisers themselves (our reading), so ask who the appraiser is and what they hold.
Designations
The Appraisal Institute of Canada gives two designations: AACI, for commercial and residential appraisals, and CRA, for residential ones (its FAQ). Its members follow its Canadian Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (CUSPAP) and carry professional liability insurance through its program (its page on what appraisers do). A lender most often names the appraisers it accepts (our reading).
How a home is valued
For a house the appraiser mostly uses the direct comparison approach, analysing completed sales, listings and pending sales of similar properties, often 3 to 10 or more of them; the cost approach, land plus the building's cost less its wear and other depreciation, is more reliable on a newer house; the income approach is typically not applied to a home. The visit takes 20 to 40 minutes, and most of the work happens after it (the Institute's pages).
The lender's appraisal
The lender uses the appraised value, not the purchase price, to set the most it will lend (the Institute's page for property owners). When the appraisal is for a mortgage, the buyer often pays the fee but the appraiser's client is the lender, and under CUSPAP the report goes to anyone else, the person who paid for it included, only with the lender's written authorization. Ask your lender whether you'll get a copy.
When it comes in low
If the price is well above the appraised value, you may not get the loan you were counting on (the Institute's page). The gap is most often filled with a larger down payment, a lower price the seller agrees to, or another lender's appraisal (our reading). While financing is a subject of your offer you must make every reasonable effort to satisfy it; if it truly can't be met the contract ends, and the deposit comes back once both sides sign a release (BCFSA, as subjects and the deposit sets out). Once you've removed subjects, a low appraisal doesn't end the contract (our reading).
Rural land and acreages
Comparable sales are fewer on rural land and further apart, so an appraiser may reach further in distance or time, and an acreage often adds less to the value than its size suggests; outbuildings, the well, the septic, the road and the house's heat weigh on the figure (our reading). The Institute lists rural, agricultural and orchard land among the property types its appraisers value. A lender may lend only on the house and part of the land; see a mortgage on a rural lot.
Using one against your assessment
A designated appraiser can prepare an appraisal to support a complaint about your assessed value (the Institute's page for property owners); the notice of complaint is due by January 31 (Assessment Act s. 33 (2)), as your assessed value sets out.
What it means for a buyer
Know before you offer who orders the appraisal and what happens if it's low. The Institute recommends working with your lender to have a designated appraiser value the property before you sign the purchase agreement; where that isn't possible, a financing subject with enough days is the protection (our reading).

Our summary of the Assessment Act (ss. 18, 33) and the Real Estate Services Act (ss. 1, 2) and Real Estate Services Regulation (B.C. Reg. 506/2004, s. 2.8) on BC Laws, the Appraisal Institute of Canada's pages for property owners, on what appraisers do and its FAQ, and BCFSA's pages as subjects and the deposit reads them, read 2026-10-26. Each lender and mortgage insurer sets its own appraisal rules; we name no appraiser, lender or fee.

Sources (read 2026-10-26; summarised in our own words unless noted): Assessment Act, RSBC 1996, c. 20, ss. 18, 33; Real Estate Services Act, SBC 2004, c. 42, ss. 1, 2; Real Estate Services Regulation, B.C. Reg. 506/2004, s. 2.8; For Residential Property Owners, Appraisal Institute of Canada; What Appraisers Do, Appraisal Institute of Canada; FAQs, Appraisal Institute of Canada.

Before you buy: who to ask

Your lender or mortgage broker
Who orders the appraisal, who pays for it, will I get a copy, and if it comes in under the price, how much more would I need down?
The appraiser
Which designation do you hold, which sales did you compare this property with, and how did you value the land, the outbuildings and the well and septic?
Your lawyer or notary
Does my financing subject cover a low appraisal, and how many days do I need for it?

Look up the lot above: its report gives what an appraiser asks about on rural land, from the road and the well to the floodplain, and the tax rates for its place.

See also your assessed value, subjects and the deposit, a mortgage on a rural lot, the mortgage stress test, closing costs, home inspections and property tax.